Stand Your Ground or Save Your Reputation? What Bud Light teaches us about Brand Crisis managment:
Think of the last advertisement that really caught your eye. It might’ve been something you disagreed with or missed its intended audience. Now imagine the advertisement turning into a worldwide controversy. What should the company do next: stand behind its original message or change the approach to protect its reputation?
In April 2023, Bud Light faced exactly this situation after doing a brand partnership with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney. What started as a minor collaboration skyrocketed into a PR disaster and raised questions from both sides about Bud Light’s brand identity.
This situation made me think of the bigger picture for advertising professionals: When a brand receives backlash, is it better to stay or retreat?
When an Advertisement Doesn’t Land as Intended:
This advertisement shared by Dylan Mulvaney was a sponsored Instagram post featuring a personalized Bud Light can that the company had sent her. They were celebrating the one-year anniversary of her “365 Days of Girlhood” series, which documented her transition.
Some consumers supported the collaboration, while others responded with not only criticism but hateful messages and calls to boycott purchasing/ drinking Bud Light. The conversation included celebrities, politicians, and consumers.
For Bud Light, this was a new approach. This situation highlighted how difficult it can be to introduce new marketing strategies when a brand has already established an audience and identity. The company was attempting to reach a younger and more diverse group of consumers, but as you can imagine, its existing audience did not respond positively.
The PR response?
The advertisement was only the beginning of their problems. How Bud Light responded became a major part of the conversation. As the backlash continued, Bud Light CEO Brendan Whitworth released a public statement saying, “The company never intended to be a part of a conversation that divides people”. The company additionally placed two of its marketing executives involved in the promotion on leave.
This response did not satisfy either side. Some consumers wanted the company to take responsibility for the advertisement, and some supporters of Mulvany felt the company had failed to publicly stand behind its collaboration and message. This response in turn created an even bigger problem. When a company makes an executive decision, it should be prepared to explain that decision and stand behind it. By this response, they put themselves at risk of being perceived as performative or ingenuine.
What Other Brands Can Learn:
Bud Light is not the first company to experience backlash and will certainly not be the last. As an Advertising and Public Relations major, I have learned a few things throughout my coursework.
- Know your audience: It is extremely important to understand your existing customers, just as or maybe more, important than identifying new audiences you want to reach.
- Prepare for different reactions: Not everyone will interpret everything the same. Companies should consider all possible responses and the implications their message sends.
- Stay consistent: It’s a bad look if a brand’s values change depending on which audience is loudest.
- Prioritize authenticity: Consumers are more likely to question a brand when its actions seem to contradict its messaging or if it is quick to retreat on controversial stances.
So, what do you think? When an advertisement hits the fan, should a company stand behind its message or change its approach to protect its reputation?
If you would like to learn more here are some informative articles:
https://hbr.org/2024/03/lessons-from-the-bud-light-boycott-one-year-later
Forrester: Lessons Learned From Bud Light’s Marketing Blunder
The Washington Post: Bud Light’s Attempt to Market to New Customers Alienated Old Ones